Skip to content
MARKET
BTC 58.015,00 ▼ -1,6 % ETH 1.640,33 ▼ -0,7 % SOL 67,670 ▼ -0,9 % XRP 0,8958 ▼ -1,4 % BNB 536,41 ▼ -0,6 % ADA 0,1402 ▼ -0,7 % DOGE 0,0541 ▼ -0,7 % USDT 0,9086 ▼ -0,2 %
EN
Thursday, November 19, 2026

Level: INTERMEDIATE 8 min

Best crypto ICOs: how to evaluate them

Looking for the best ICOs is looking in the wrong direction. A better approach is learning to filter out bad projects using eight criteria and a clear legal framework.

The essentials

Updated 11/11/2026 · 14:17
  1. 01An ICO is a public token sale to fund a project, carrying very high risk and potential total loss.
  2. 02Evaluated using 8 criteria: team, white paper, tokenomics, audit, product, funds, regulation, and liquidity.
  3. 03In the EU, MiCA requires a notified white paper and issuer liability, with some exceptions.
Una moneda de bitcoin grande rodeada de muchas otras monedas

Written by

Tadeo Bellver Zorrilla

Derivatives & Trading Specialist

Reviewed by Álvaro Mendizabal Orozco, Compliance & Platform Legal Reviewer

Published ·Reading time: 8 min

This article is also available in:Español (Spanish)Italiano (Italian)Français (French)Português (Portuguese)Deutsch (German)

An ICO, short for Initial Coin Offering, is a public token sale used to fund a project. It resembles an initial public offering, but without the traditional oversight of a regulated market. People looking for the best crypto ICOs often expect a list of winners. It is worth stating right from the start that such a list does not exist and this article does not contain one.

What you will find instead is a method. We will examine how an ICO works, how it differs from an IEO or an IDO, the eight criteria we use to discard proposals, the warning signs that should make you close the tab, and what European regulations say. Risk comes first and any potential profit comes second, because that is how serious analysis must be ordered.

What is an ICO and where does it come from

In an ICO, a project team sells tokens, which are digital units issued on a blockchain, in exchange for cryptocurrencies or fiat money. The funds raised are used to finance development. Buyers receive their tokens when the sale closes or according to a release schedule, known as vesting, which unlocks tokens in batches.

The most frequently cited historical case is Ethereum’s ICO in 2014. The major boom arrived in 2017 and 2018, when offerings without a product, verifiable team, or realistic promises proliferated. A large share of those ICOs failed or turned out to be scams, and that memory should set the tone for any current analysis.

If you do not yet master the foundations, start with the guide on what a blockchain is, because without it the terms in this article lose their meaning.

How an ICO works step by step

The process follows a fairly stable sequence. Knowing it helps identify where the risk is concentrated, which is almost never in the technology and almost always in the people and the timeline.

  1. The team publishes a white paper, the document describing the project, token distribution, and schedule.
  2. The sale opens and buyers send cryptocurrencies or money.
  3. When the sale closes, tokens are delivered all at once or according to a vesting schedule.
  4. Later on, if listed, the token begins trading and gains liquidity.

That final step is not guaranteed. Some tokens are never listed, or they trade with so little volume that selling without crashing the price becomes impossible.

ICO, IEO, IDO, and airdrop: what changes

Over time, variants appeared. These differences matter because they change who filters the project and who is accountable if something goes wrong.

  • IEO. The sale is organized by an exchange, which acts as an intermediary and showcase.
  • IDO. The sale takes place on a decentralized exchange, without prior filtering by a company.
  • Launchpads pool sales from multiple projects onto a single platform.
  • Airdrops distribute free tokens to raise awareness of a protocol.

To understand where IDOs are traded, the guide on what a decentralized exchange is will help. My criterion is clear: an exchange organizing a sale does not make it safe, and in an IDO the responsibility to research falls almost entirely on you.

How much you can lose: an example with numbers

Risk is best understood with simple math. Imagine you buy ICO tokens for 500 euros. If the project is abandoned, the token delisted, or the team disappears, the reasonable scenario is losing the entire 500 euros, not just a portion.

Now add vesting. Suppose the team and early investors receive 40% of the tokens and unlock them after 6 months. When that block hits the market, supply increases abruptly and the price can drop sharply if sellers outnumber buyers.

This is why the unlock schedule matters just as much as the project. A token can be technically interesting and still lose value due to poor distribution. These tokens carry very high risk, and total loss is a possible outcome, not an exaggeration.

Golden rule: invest only what you can afford to lose completely, check who is issuing the token in official CNMV and ESMA registries, and distrust any project that rushes you.

How to evaluate the best crypto ICOs: 8 criteria

These criteria are not buy recommendations. They are meant for elimination. If a project fails several of them, there is no need to keep reading.

  1. Identified and verifiable team. An anonymous team does not guarantee fraud, but it eliminates any enforceable accountability.
  2. Technical white paper. It must outline a real problem and explain how the token solves it, rather than just making promises.
  3. Tokenomics. Look at the allocation between the team, investors, and the public, the vesting schedule, and inflation.
  4. Independent audit of the smart contract, the code managing the sale, and the tokens.
  5. Existence of a product or prototype that you can verify on your own.
  6. Transparency regarding raised funds and their custody.

Two criteria remain. The seventh is regulatory compliance and the issuer’s home country: who is accountable and to which authority. The eighth is expected liquidity after listing, meaning whether there will be a place to sell and at what volume.

Order the criteria by weight. Team, audit, and tokenomics quickly eliminate projects because they address accountability, code reliability, and who keeps the tokens. Product and liquidity matter next, and regulation determines whether you have any recourse when something goes wrong.

A practical example: a project with a brilliant white paper, but with 70% of the tokens in the hands of the team and no audit, fails on tokenomics and security. Dismiss it without remorse.

Red flags in a fraudulent ICO

Scams follow a recognizable script. If several of these warning signs appear at once, the right decision is not to participate.

  • Guaranteed returns. No legitimate investment offers them.
  • Time pressure: “last hours,” “allocation almost sold out.”
  • Bonuses for bringing friends, a typical pyramid scheme mechanic.
  • Anonymous team and a newly created website.
  • Promotion by paid influencers.
  • Unaudited contracts.

A common mistake deserves separate mention: trusting the Telegram community. Project groups are full of people with conflicting interests, fake accounts, and moderators who delete doubts. Anyone posting opinions there is rarely neutral.

To expand on this review, the guide on crypto scams covers the most common frauds and how to react.

What MiCA says about public offerings of crypto assets

In the European Union, the MiCA regulation, number 2023/1114, governs public offerings of crypto assets other than stablecoins. It requires a white paper notified to the competent authority, truthful information, and issuer liability.

A frequently misunderstood point deserves clarification: the white paper is notified, not approved by the authority. Its existence does not mean the regulator has endorsed the project. Furthermore, article 4 provides exceptions, such as offerings to fewer than 150 persons per Member State, those directed at qualified investors, or those totaling less than 1 million euros over 12 months.

MiCA applies in full as of December 30, 2024, and stablecoin rules apply as of June 30, 2024. In Spain, according to the CNMV MiCA portal, the transitional period for providers ended on July 1, 2026. Since then, only authorized providers operate, which you can check in the CNMV provider registry.

Outside the EU, the scenario changes. In the United States, the SEC has treated many ICOs as securities offerings.

ICO taxation in Spain

Gains are taxed under the savings income bracket of the IRPF (personal income tax): 19% up to 6,000 euros, 21% up to 50,000, 23% up to 200,000, 27% up to 300,000, and 30% above, starting in 2025 under Law 7/2024. The FIFO method applies, which assumes units purchased first are sold first. Exchanging one crypto for another or paying with it is also taxable.

Tokens received, for example through an airdrop, may be taxed as income or capital gains depending on the case. Consulting an advisor is recommended here, because the classification is not automatic.

Starting January 1, 2026, the DAC8 directive obliges providers to collect and report client data to tax authorities. Form 721, with a deadline from January 1 to March 31, must be filed by residents whose cryptocurrencies held by third-party custodians abroad exceed 50,000 euros as of December 31. Cryptos held in a self-custody wallet do not count; if you want to set one up, review what a wallet is. For other tax obligations, the guide on crypto and the Spanish tax agency provides further detail.

What the CNMV and ESMA warn about

European authorities have been insisting on the same message for years. Crypto assets have no investment guarantee fund, consumer protection is limited, and everything invested can be lost. The joint warning from European supervisors lays this out clearly, and the CNMV, alongside the Banco de España, has also been warning about scams circulating on social media.

Our editorial conclusion is simple. We view ICOs as terrain for those who already master the sector and accept losing everything. More useful than searching for the best ones is learning to discard the bad ones, and with eight criteria and a bit of patience you will have already ruled out the majority.

Frequently asked questions

What is an ICO?

It is a public token sale used to fund a project. Ethereum’s in 2014 is the most frequently cited historical case.

Are ICOs legal in Spain?

Within the EU, public offerings of crypto assets are regulated by MiCA, which requires a notified white paper and issuer liability. Exceptions exist, such as very small offerings or those directed at qualified investors.

What is the difference between an ICO, an IEO, and an IDO?

In an IEO, the sale is organized by an exchange. In an IDO, it takes place on a decentralized exchange. A classic ICO is launched by the project team itself.

How do I spot a fraudulent ICO?

Distrust anonymous teams, guaranteed returns, time pressure, bonuses for recruiting friends, unaudited contracts, and promotions by paid influencers.

Are tokens received in an ICO or an airdrop taxable?

They can be taxed as income or capital gains depending on the case. It is advisable to consult an advisor or review binding rulings from the Directorate-General for Taxes.

This content is educational and does not constitute financial advice or an investment recommendation (NFA). Do your own research (DYOR), do not invest money you need in the short term, and keep your country’s tax obligations in mind. And you, do you know how much you would be willing to lose completely before entering an ICO?

Sources and risk warning

SOURCES CONSULTED

Crypto assets are highly volatile and you can lose everything you invest. This article is informational and is not financial advice. Prices are those at the time of publication.

How we verify dataEditorial policySpotted an error? Tell us

KEEP READING

More in Academy

See all